Resources / The Red Team · Perspective
Strengths Are the Only Currency
What an evaluation board can actually award, and how to write so it can award it to you.
Ask a proposal team what their draft has going for it and you will hear about effort: the hours, the reviews, the senior people assigned, the care taken. Ask an evaluator the same question and you will hear a shorter list, in a different vocabulary. Evaluators do not award effort. They award documented strengths, and strengths are the only currency the evaluation room accepts.
What a strength actually is
Under FAR Part 15, proposals are evaluated against the factors and subfactors stated in Section M of the solicitation. Within that frame, a strength is not a compliment. It is a specific finding: an aspect of the proposal that exceeds a requirement in a way that benefits the government, or that reduces risk in a way the government cares about. Both halves matter. Exceeding a requirement the government does not value is not a strength. Benefiting the government in a way the proposal never connects to a requirement is not a strength either, because the evaluator has nowhere to record it.
This is why so much good work goes unrewarded. A firm may genuinely offer more than the requirement asks: deeper staffing, a better tool, a faster transition. If the proposal presents that surplus as background color rather than as a claim tied to the factor being scored, the evaluator reads it as description, not as a finding. Description fills pages. Findings fill score sheets.
The other side of the ledger
The same frame produces the findings no one wants. A weakness is an aspect of the proposal that increases the risk of unsuccessful performance. A significant weakness is that risk made serious. A deficiency is a material failure: the proposal does not meet a government requirement, or combines significant weaknesses in a way that makes the risk unacceptable. These are not insults; they are categories, and evaluators are required to sort what they find into them.
Notice what follows. The evaluator's job is not to balance your effort against your errors. It is to record findings in both directions and let the record carry the decision. A proposal with three documented strengths and one deficiency is not "mostly strong." The deficiency stands on its own line, and in many evaluations it ends the discussion.
Write the sentence the evaluator needs
A strength enters the record through a sentence an evaluator writes, and that sentence has to be defensible in a consensus room and, later, in a source selection decision document. The practical test for any claim in your proposal is simple: could the evaluator lift your sentence, nearly as written, into the record? If your claim is specific, quantified where it can be, tied to the requirement it exceeds, and explicit about the benefit to the government, the answer is yes, and you have done the evaluator's hardest work for them. If your claim is general ("a proven, world-class approach"), the evaluator would have to build the finding themselves, under time pressure, for a firm they do not work for. They will not. The claim dies as a claim.
Placement matters as much as language. Evaluators read in sections, against the factor in front of them. A strength described in the management volume does not rescue a technical volume that never makes the claim where the technical factor is scored. Write each strength where it will be looked for, state it in the terms of the factor, and repeat the discipline for every factor and subfactor in Section M. That is the Assess stage of the CORE Method applied before submission instead of after the debrief.
The discipline, stated plainly
Before a proposal goes out, list every factor and subfactor. For each one, write the strength you intend the evaluator to record, in one sentence, in the evaluator's vocabulary: what exceeds the requirement, and why the government benefits. Then check that the proposal states that sentence, specifically, in the section where that factor is scored. Where you cannot write the sentence, you have found the real state of the proposal, and it is better found by you than recorded by the board.
Effort is what a proposal costs you. Strengths are what it earns. Only one of those appears in the record.
Know which strengths your draft actually documents?
An Evaluator Score Sheet tells you, factor by factor, before the board does.
Explore an Engagement More from Resources